Opioid Cases in Federal Court: The Threat to Doctors Who Prescribe Painkillers

Categories: Medicare Lawyer

opioid crisis

How the DEA and DOJ Decide When to Charge Doctors for Opioid Fraud and Diversion

Opioid addiction is a major problem in the United States, and the public is demanding action to stop it. Feeling the weight of that pressure, politicians have pledged to cut drugs off at their source.

For drugs like cocaine and methamphetamine, that might mean street corners, trap houses, or even the border. But for prescription drugs (currently the leading cause of accidental overdose and death in this country, and a notorious “gateway” to harder drug abuse) “the source” is sometimes a prescription pad in a doctor’s office.

Accordingly, federal authorities are employing a wide range of measures to combat prescription painkiller abuse as well as the drugs they pave a path for: carfentanil, fentanyl, and heroin.

Those measures include noble efforts like education and community outreach. But increasingly, they also include aggressively prosecuting doctors, nurses, pharmacists, and any other healthcare providers who prescribe, administer, or distribute prescription pain medications.

In surveying the opioid cases currently on the federal dockets and those that have dominated Department of Justice press announcements in the last five years, it is clear that the defendants are not limited to fake M.D.s or shady pill-mill doctors who dole out dangerous drugs for cash.

On the contrary, many of the people caught up in these cases are doctors with thriving practices and sterling reputations. They treat patients who are in dire need of pain relief (or perhaps patients who are already opioid-dependent) for whom a pain medication prescription may be a critical part of their recovery.

In terms of the specific criminal charges, opioid cases against healthcare providers range from overbilling Medicaid or Medicare (healthcare fraud) to writing or selling prescriptions for patients who don’t need them (drug trafficking or drug diversion) among a host of other opioid charges.

Federal investigations tend to spiral into major ordeals very quickly. The consequences can be devastating. The penalties may even include decades in prison, not to mention inconceivable fines and the revocation of medical licenses.

If you are a healthcare provider treating patients who struggle with pain or addiction, please don’t take the threat of a DEA, DOJ, OIG, or FBI investigation lightly. Talk to an experienced healthcare criminal defense lawyer for advice on compliance and strategies for legal defense right away.

How Is the DOJ Building Opioid Cases against Healthcare Providers?

Last fall, on August 2, 2017, U.S. Attorney General Jeff Sessions announced that the DOJ would form of a new Opioid Fraud and Abuse Detection Unit. Among other things, the DOJ would now assign teams of federal prosecutors to various regions around the country, tasking them specifically with addressing opioid-related Medicare fraud.

As part of that same effort, the DOJ also:

  • Restructured the DEA to strengthen and streamline its focus on prosecuting doctors for drug trafficking and diversion;
  • Designated an “opioid coordinator” at eachU.S. Attorney’s Office in the country; and
  • Issued millions of dollars in grants to state and local law enforcement (specifically to aid in policing illegal opioids).

Less than three months later, AG Sessions announced that the newly reassigned prosecutors were already issuing indictments for the arrest and prosecution of healthcare professionals around the country. And they’ve only picked up steam since then. (This is in addition, of course, to the Medicare Fraud Strike Force, which also routinely audits and raids medical clinics and refers its findings to agencies like the DEA and FBI.)

To build an opioid case against a doctor or pharmacist, the government will often begin by:

  • Approaching patients, colleagues, or employees (whether past or present) as potential informants
  • Securing search and seizure warrants
  • Conducting secret surveillance
  • Using undercover agents
  • Scrutinizing claims for payment, patient records, and other documentation

Even if you haven’t done anything wrong, a single careless statement or a period of sloppy documentation in your office could lead to an investigation.

As the government’s efforts to combat the opioid crisis grow more stringent, doctors are at greater risk of being investigated, prosecuted, and sentenced for a federal felony they never intended to commit.

Any provider targeted as a suspect should take swift and strategic action to protect themselves from undeserved consequences by contacting a healthcare criminal defense attorney as soon as possible.

Factors Prosecutors Consider When Deciding When to Pursue Opioid Cases

In addition to gathering the kinds of evidence described above, federal agents will consider a number of other factors when deciding whether to bring an opioid case, including:

  • Your practice’s opioid prescription rates (how often do you prescribe painkillers for your patients?)
  • Irregularities in Medicare, Medicaid, and Tricare billing data
  • Patient death rate (how many of your patients have died within 60 days of receiving opioid medications?)
  • Patient demographics
  • Whether you have documented an examination with each patient prior to changing their prescriptions
  • Whether your practice is located in one of the 12 federally identified “hot spots” for opioid fraud and abuse (see below)

The 12 Districts of the U.S. Opioid Fraud and Abuse Detection Unit

The 12 federal districts selected to participate in the DOJ’s Opioid Fraud and Abuse Detection Unit are:

  1. Middle District of Florida
  2. Eastern District of Michigan
  3. Northern District of Alabama
  4. Eastern District of Tennessee
  5. District of Nevada
  6. Eastern District of Kentucky
  7. District of Maryland
  8. Western District of Pennsylvania
  9. Southern District of Ohio
  10. Eastern District of California
  11. Middle District of North Carolina
  12. Southern District of West Virginia

While the government can and does conduct investigations nationwide, those whose clinics are located within these 12 twelve districts should be especially cautious when treating patients for pain or opioid addiction.

Talk to Our Defense Attorneys about Your Opioid Case

Oberheiden, P.C.is a healthcare fraud defense firm representing doctors, nurses, pharmacists, and medical executives across the country.

Our team consists of highly experienced healthcare criminal defense lawyers, many of them former DOJ prosecutors,who now represent individual white-collar professionals and medical organizations instead.

If you are under suspicion of any opioid-related offense, please contact our office for a free and confidential consultation right away. We’re standing by.

Oberheiden, P.C.
Compliance – Litigation – Defense
(888) 356-4634
This information has been prepared for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. This information may constitute attorney advertising in some jurisdictions. Merely reading this information does not create an attorney-client relationship. Prior results do not guarantee similar outcomes in the future. Oberheiden, P.C. is a Texas firm with its headquarters in Dallas. The attorney on record limits his practice to federal law.